Many factors affect the cost of car insurance in the U.S., including your location. Car insurance companies consider your state, city and ZIP code when calculating your personalized premium. Car insurance rates tend to be the most expensive in big cities where there are higher accident rates, more claims filed and other risks, like vehicle thefts.

In this article, we’ll look at the most expensive cities for car insurance in every U.S. state and share which insurance companies offer the most affordable rates in the most expensive cities.

Key Highlights
  • Car insurance rates in big cities tend to be higher than in small towns.
  • Premiums can vary significantly between ZIP codes in the same city.
  • Comparing car insurance quotes will help you find the cheapest policy for your location and situation.
author-img
Written by:
Elizabeth Rivelli
Contributing Researcher
Elizabeth Rivelli is a freelance writer who covers insurance. Her areas of expertise are life insurance, car insurance, property insurance and health insurance. Elizabeth has appeared in dozens of online publications, including Investopedia, CNET and Bankrate. She has also written for several insurance companies.
author
Reviewed by:
Laura Longero
reviewer icon
Executive Editor
Laura Longero is an insurance expert and Executive Editor at CarInsurance.com, where she specializes in helping consumers navigate the complexities of the financial and insurance industries. She has 15 years of experience educating people about finance and car insurance. Prior to joining CarInsurance.com, she worked as a reporter and editor at the USA Today Network. Her expertise provides readers with practical guidance, helping them make informed choices about their financial and insurance needs.
ZIP Code
Please enter valid ZIP

Highest car insurance rates by city

While your state significantly impacts your car insurance premium, your city does as well. The city of North Miami Beach in Florida has the most expensive car insurance at $297 per month. Tarzana, California comes in second at $286 per month, followed by Marksville, Louisiana at $285 per month.

Below, you can see the most expensive cities for car insurance in every U.S. state, including the average annual cost and average monthly cost in each city.

Most expensive cities for car insurance in the U.S.
State City Average annual cost Average monthly cost
AlaskaAnchorage$1,950$162
AlabamaTarrant$2,084$174
ArkansasSnow Lake$2,205$184
ArizonaPhoenix$2,251$188
CaliforniaTarzana$3,430$286
ColoradoCope$2,729$227
ConnecticutBridgeport$2,334$195
Washington, D.C.Washington Navy Yard$2,157$180
DelawareDelaware City$2,361$197
FloridaNorth Miami Beach$3,570$297
GeorgiaClarkston$2,904$242
HawaiiWaikoloa Village$1,630$136
IowaBedford$2,053$171
IdahoPorthill$1,549$129
IllinoisCalumet City$2,108$176
IndianaGary$2,110$176
KansasAlmena$2,203$184
KentuckyFreeburn$2,808$234
LouisianaMarksville$3,420$285
MassachusettsRoxbury$2,993$249
MarylandGwynn Oak$2,447$204
MaineCutler$1,261$105
MichiganHamtramck$3,370$281
MinnesotaBrooklyn Center$2,232$186
MissouriPagedale$2,456$205
MississippiWashington$2,309$192
MontanaLodge Grass$2,471$206
North CarolinaNewell$2,136$178
North DakotaSelfridge$1,860$155
NebraskaHayes Center$2,273$189
New HampshireManchester$1,436$120
New JerseyNewark$2,641$220
New MexicoKirtland Air Force Base$2,332$194
NevadaSunrise Manor$2,767$231
New YorkWoodhaven$3,030$252
OhioCleveland$1,643$137
OklahomaWarr Acres$2,478$206
OregonGresham$2,077$173
PennsylvaniaPhiladelphia$2,782$232
Rhode IslandJohnston$2,644$220
South CarolinaMiley$2,389$199
South DakotaOglala$2,871$239
TennesseeMemphis$2,161$180
TexasBalch Springs$2,384$199
UtahWest Valley City$2,179$182
VirginiaSpringfield$1,684$140
VermontTaftsville$1,367$114
WashingtonTukwila$2,085$174
WisconsinWebster$2,033$169
West VirginiaGenoa$2,275$190
WyomingTeton Village$1,825$152

Most expensive ZIP codes for car insurance in the top 10 U.S. cities

Car insurance premiums tend to be the most expensive in big cities. The most expensive ZIP codes are 90010 in Los Angeles, ZIP code 11235 in New York and 19125 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.

However, car insurance rates can also vary depending on your ZIP code within the city. Here are the most expensive ZIP codes for car insurance in the top 10 largest cities.

Most expensive ZIP codes for car insurance in the top 10 U.S. cities
StateCity ZIP codeAverage annual costAverage monthly cost
New YorkNew York11235$3,157 $263 
CaliforniaLos Angeles90010$3,471 $289 
IllinoisChicago60637$2,218 $185 
TexasHouston77076$2,506 $209 
ArizonaPhoenix85015$2,500 $208 
PennsylvaniaPhiladelphia19125$3,012 $251 
TexasSan Antonio78202$2,355 $196 
CaliforniaSan Diego92135$2,941 $245 
TexasDallas75215$2,545 $212 
TexasAustin78617$2,057 $171 

Which insurance companies offer affordable rates in the most expensive cities?

When shopping for car insurance, it’s essential to compare rates from several companies to find the most affordable policy for your location and unique driver profile. This is especially true if you live in one of the more expensive cities for auto insurance.

In New York, Progressive and NYC Insurance offer the cheapest car insurance rates. In Los Angeles, Geico and CSAA Insurance (AAA) offer the cheapest rates. In Chicago, Progressive and Auto Club Group – ACG (AAA) offer the cheapest policies.

In the table below, you can see the cheapest car insurance companies in the most expensive U.S. cities, as well as the average annual and monthly premium for each insurer.

Car insurance companies with the cheapest rates in the most expensive cities
State City  Company Average annual cost Average monthly cost
New YorkNew YorkProgressive$1,640 $137 
New YorkNew YorkNYCM Insurance$2,358 $196 
New YorkNew YorkGeico$2,401 $200 
New YorkNew YorkState Farm$2,537 $211 
New YorkNew YorkThe Hanover$3,120 $260 
New YorkNew YorkAllstate$3,355 $280 
New YorkNew YorkErie Insurance$3,536 $295 
New YorkNew YorkUSAA$2,680 $223 
CaliforniaLos AngelesGeico$2,805 $234 
CaliforniaLos AngelesCSAA Insurance (AAA)$2,845 $237 
CaliforniaLos AngelesMercury Insurance$2,941 $245 
CaliforniaLos AngelesProgressive$3,062 $255 
CaliforniaLos AngelesKemper$3,411 $284 
CaliforniaLos AngelesTravelers$3,471 $289 
CaliforniaLos AngelesAllstate$3,516 $293 
CaliforniaLos AngelesNationwide$3,544 $295 
CaliforniaLos AngelesAuto Club Enterprises (AAA)$3,558 $296 
CaliforniaLos AngelesState Farm$3,688 $307 
CaliforniaLos AngelesFarmers$3,748 $312 
CaliforniaLos AngelesUSAA$2,238 $187 
IllinoisChicagoProgressive$1,366 $114 
IllinoisChicagoAuto Club Group – ACG (AAA)$1,402 $117 
IllinoisChicagoTravelers$1,415 $118 
IllinoisChicagoGeico$1,608 $134 
IllinoisChicagoAuto-Owners$1,811 $151 
IllinoisChicagoErie Insurance$2,083 $174 
IllinoisChicagoCountry Financial$2,134 $178 
IllinoisChicagoState Farm$2,254 $188 
IllinoisChicagoAllstate$3,419 $285 
IllinoisChicagoUSAA$2,066 $172 
TexasHoustonTexas Farm Bureau$1,530 $127 
TexasHoustonNationwide$1,640 $137 
TexasHoustonGeico$1,940 $162 
TexasHoustonRedpoint Insurance$1,964 $164 
TexasHoustonState Farm$2,278 $190 
TexasHoustonAuto Club Enterprises (AAA)$2,426 $202 
TexasHoustonAllstate$3,352 $279 
TexasHoustonProgressive$3,655 $305 
TexasHoustonUSAA$2,102 $175 
ArizonaPhoenixGeico$1,582 $132 
ArizonaPhoenixTravelers$1,785 $149 
ArizonaPhoenixAuto-Owners$2,140 $178 
ArizonaPhoenixNationwide$2,208 $184 
ArizonaPhoenixProgressive$2,427 $202 
ArizonaPhoenixAllstate$2,769 $231 
ArizonaPhoenixState Farm$2,831 $236 
ArizonaPhoenixFarmers$2,972 $248 
ArizonaPhoenixUSAA$1,741 $145 
PennsylvaniaPhiladelphiaTravelers$1,585 $132 
PennsylvaniaPhiladelphiaNationwide$2,442 $203 
PennsylvaniaPhiladelphiaDonegal Insurance$2,758 $230 
PennsylvaniaPhiladelphiaGeico$2,977 $248 
PennsylvaniaPhiladelphiaErie Insurance$3,150 $263 
PennsylvaniaPhiladelphiaWestfield Insurance$3,374 $281 
PennsylvaniaPhiladelphiaState Farm$3,418 $285 
PennsylvaniaPhiladelphiaAllstate$3,428 $286 
PennsylvaniaPhiladelphiaProgressive$3,449 $287 
PennsylvaniaPhiladelphiaUSAA$2,791 $233 
TexasSan AntonioTexas Farm Bureau$1,384 $115 
TexasSan AntonioNationwide$1,522 $127 
TexasSan AntonioRedpoint Insurance$1,610 $134 
TexasSan AntonioGeico$1,774 $148 
TexasSan AntonioAuto Club Enterprises (AAA)$2,056 $171 
TexasSan AntonioState Farm$2,074 $173 
TexasSan AntonioAllstate$3,026 $252 
TexasSan AntonioProgressive$3,189 $266 
TexasSan AntonioFarmers$4,130 $344 
TexasSan AntonioUSAA$1,932 $161 
CaliforniaSan DiegoGeico$1,706 $142 
CaliforniaSan DiegoMercury Insurance$1,888 $157 
CaliforniaSan DiegoProgressive$1,986 $165 
CaliforniaSan DiegoKemper$2,210 $184 
CaliforniaSan DiegoTravelers$2,251 $188 
CaliforniaSan DiegoAuto Club Enterprises (AAA)$2,394 $200 
CaliforniaSan DiegoAllstate$2,496 $208 
CaliforniaSan DiegoState Farm$2,616 $218 
CaliforniaSan DiegoNationwide$2,744 $229 
CaliforniaSan DiegoCSAA Insurance (AAA)$2,845 $237 
CaliforniaSan DiegoFarmers$2,943 $245 
CaliforniaSan DiegoUSAA$1,806 $150 
TexasDallasTexas Farm Bureau$1,644 $137 
TexasDallasNationwide$1,690 $141 
TexasDallasGeico$1,863 $155 
TexasDallasRedpoint Insurance$1,948 $162 
TexasDallasState Farm$2,290 $191 
TexasDallasAuto Club Enterprises (AAA)$2,397 $200 
TexasDallasProgressive$3,496 $291 
TexasDallasAllstate$3,596 $300 
TexasDallasUSAA$2,014 $168 
TexasAustinNationwide$1,406 $117 
TexasAustinTexas Farm Bureau$1,418 $118 
TexasAustinRedpoint Insurance$1,511 $126 
TexasAustinGeico$1,615 $135 
TexasAustinState Farm$1,922 $160 
TexasAustinAuto Club Enterprises (AAA)$1,980 $165 
TexasAustinProgressive$2,836 $236 
TexasAustinUSAA$1,827 $152 
TexasAustinAllstate$2,899 $242 

Can moving to a different neighborhood within the same city change my car insurance rate?

Moving to a different neighborhood within the same city can cause your car insurance premium to change. For example, if you move to a neighborhood with a lower crime rate than your old neighborhood, it’s possible that your rate could decrease. Or, if you move to a new neighborhood where more insurance claims are filed, your premium could increase.

The only way to know how much you will pay for car insurance in a new neighborhood is to get personalized rate quotes for your new address. If your rate is going to increase, consider getting new quotes from a different carrier to see if you can find cheaper coverage.

What factors other than location influence car insurance rates?

The cost of car insurance is different for every driver. In addition to your location, some of the biggest factors that can impact rates include:

  • Age: Teens and young drivers typically pay the highest rates for car insurance. For most drivers, premiums decrease steadily over time.
  • Gender: Because female drivers have fewer accidents than male drivers, women usually pay slightly less for car insurance than men.
  • Credit score: In many states, car insurance companies use a credit-based insurance score to determine the cost of your policy. 
  • Driving record: Drivers with a history of accidents, speeding tickets, and other violations usually pay higher rates for car insurance than people with a clean record.
  • Vehicle type: Some vehicles are more expensive to insure than others. For example, insuring a brand new vehicle usually costs more than insuring a used car.
  • Coverage types and limits: The type of car insurance coverage and coverage limits will impact your rate. Adding optional endorsements will also raise your premium.
  • Deductible: For policies that require a deductible, like collision insurance, choosing a higher deductible will result in a lower premium, and vice versa.
  • Insurance company: Every insurance company charges different rates, even for the same types and amounts of coverage.

What makes car insurance expensive in certain cities?

There are multiple reasons why car insurance premiums can be more expensive in certain cities.

“Insurers are focused on assessing risk when determining rates, and every city has its own unique set of risks as it relates to crime rates, frequency of accidents, population density, weather, road conditions, and average claims history — all factors that can affect risk level and ultimately, insurance premiums,” says Justin Yoshizawa, director of product management state at Mercury Insurance.

“For example, if a policyholder lives in a city that has a higher frequency of accidents, premiums will be higher because the possibility of that policyholder filing a claim is greater,” adds Yoshizawa.

Other factors that can affect insurance rates and vary by location include the cost and frequency of litigation, medical care, and the prevalence of auto insurance fraud.

The cost of auto repairs can also impact rates in a specific city. In areas with higher repair costs, insurance companies might set higher premiums to offset their claim costs.

Check out the 10 most important factors that affect car insurance rates

Strategic ways to reduce my car insurance premiums

There are several ways to reduce your car insurance premiums, no matter where you live. Here are several strategies that can help you get cheaper insurance:

  1. Take advantage of discounts: Many car insurance companies offer discounts to help drivers save money on their auto insurance policy.
  2. Shop around: Car insurance companies charge different rates, even for the same coverage. Shop around and get quotes from a few carriers to find the cheapest premium – especially if circumstances have changed such as adding a teen driver, getting a speeding ticket or getting a different vehicle.
  3. Improve your credit score: In most states, your credit history is one of the factors that can affect your premium. Improving your credit score can help you lock in a lower annual rate.
  4. Bundle two policies: Most insurers provide discounts to drivers who bundle their car insurance with another policy, like home insurance or renters insurance.
  5. Choose higher deductibles: For policies that require a deductible, like collision and comprehensive insurance, selecting a higher deductible will result in a lower premium. However, remember that you should have the deductible amount in savings if you choose a higher deductible in case you need to file a claim.

Check out our experts’ recommendations for the most expensive and cheapest car insurance rates by ZIP code

The bottom line: Most expensive car insurance rates by city

Some cities have higher car insurance rates than others. Additionally, car insurance premiums can vary even more depending on your ZIP code. Location-specific factors like the number of claims filed, the number of accidents reported, and vehicle theft rates can all affect the cost of auto insurance in a specific place.

Before you purchase a car insurance policy, make sure to get quotes from at least three insurance companies and compare them to see which one can offer you the best deal for your location, driver profile and coverage needs. 

You can also reduce your car insurance premium by taking advantage of discounts, bundling your policies, improving your credit and selecting higher deductibles.

Resources & Methodology

Source

Insurance Information Institute. “What determines the price of an auto insurance policy?” Accessed August 2024. 

Methodology

To study the most expensive U.S. cities for car insurance, we analyzed car insurance quotes in 51 states, nearly 30,000 cities, and more than 34,000 ZIP codes. We received quotes for 40-year-old male and female drivers with a good insurance score and no violations, driving 10,000 miles per year. The vehicle we used for our sample quotes was a 2023 Honda Accord LX. Quotes are for a full coverage policy with liability coverage limits of 100/300/100 and a $500 deductible for collision and comprehensive insurance.

Laura Longero

Ask the Insurance Expert

Laura Longero

Executive Editor

Laura Longero is an insurance expert and Executive Editor at CarInsurance.com, where she specializes in helping consumers navigate the complexities of the financial and insurance industries. She has 15 years of experience educating people about finance and car insurance. Prior to joining CarInsurance.com, she worked as a reporter and editor at the USA Today Network. Her expertise provides readers with practical guidance, helping them make informed choices about their financial and insurance needs.

John McCormick

Ask the Insurance Expert

John McCormick

Editorial Director

John is the editorial director for CarInsurance.com, Insurance.com and Insure.com. Before joining QuinStreet, John was a deputy editor at The Wall Street Journal and had been an editor and reporter at a number of other media outlets where he covered insurance, personal finance, and technology.

Leslie Kasperowicz

Ask the Insurance Expert

Leslie Kasperowicz

Executive Editor

Leslie Kasperowicz is an insurance educator and content creation professional with nearly two decades of experience first directly in the insurance industry at Farmers Insurance and then as a writer, researcher, and educator for insurance shoppers writing for sites like ExpertInsuranceReviews.com and InsuranceHotline.com and managing content, now at CarInsurance.com.

Nupur Gambhir

Ask the Insurance Expert

Nupur Gambhir

Managing Editor

Nupur Gambhir is a content editor and licensed life, health, and disability insurance expert. She has extensive experience bringing brands to life and has built award-nominated campaigns for travel and tech. Her insurance expertise has been featured in Bloomberg News, Forbes Advisor, CNET, Fortune, Slate, Real Simple, Lifehacker, The Financial Gym, and the end-of-life planning service.

Please Enter Valid Question. Min 50 to max 250 characters are allowed. Only (& ? , .) charcters are allowed.
Please Enter Valid Email.
Error: Security check failed
Thank You, Your message has been received. Our team of auto insurance experts typically answers questions within five working days. Note that due to the volume of questions we receive, not all may be answered. Due to technical error, please try again later.
author image
Contributing Researcher

Elizabeth Rivelli is a freelance writer who covers insurance. Her areas of expertise are life insurance, car insurance, property insurance and health insurance. Elizabeth has appeared in dozens of online publications, including Investopedia, CNET and Bankrate. She has also written for several insurance companies.