CarInsurance.com Insights
- File a police report immediately to document the theft; this helps with replacements and fraud prevention.
- Contact your auto insurance provider as soon as possible to request a replacement insurance card and flag your account.
- Report the stolen registration to your state DMV and request a duplicate — procedures and fees vary by state.
- Stolen documents contain sensitive information that can be used for identity theft and vehicle fraud.
- Monitor your accounts and consider extra protections like credit monitoring or identity theft alerts after the incident.
Car registration and insurance cards contain personal and vehicle details such as your name, address, vehicle identification number (VIN) and policy information. If these fall into the wrong hands, criminals could exploit them for identity theft, counterfeit documents or fraudulent insurance claims.
These documents aren’t just pieces of paper — they’re tied to your legal right to operate a vehicle and your insurance coverage. Prompt action helps protect you from future legal or financial issues.
Step‑by‑step actions to take following a theft
File a Police Report
As soon as you discover the theft, contact local law enforcement to report the stolen items. A police report serves as an official record of the incident and is often required when requesting replacements from your DMV or insurer.
Notify Your Insurance Company
Next, call your auto insurance provider to report the theft. They can issue a new insurance card and may flag your account to watch for suspicious activity — such as fraudulent claims made in your name.
Contact Your State DMV
Each state’s Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) has its own process for replacing stolen registration documents. In many states, you’ll need to provide the police report, pay a replacement fee and possibly show additional ID. In places like California, you complete a replacement request with the DMV.
Keep in mind that state procedures vary widely — some require in‑person visits, others allow online applications with document upload. Always check your specific state DMV for details.
Help prevent identity theft and fraud
Because your registration and insurance card contain sensitive personal information, there’s a risk of identity theft after theft.
Monitoring your credit reports and financial accounts for unusual activity can help catch fraud early. Some people also opt for identity theft protection services that provide alerts and remediation support.
How to protect your documents in the future
Once you’ve resolved the immediate problem, consider safer habits to reduce future risk:
- Don’t leave original documents in your car overnight — theft risk increases when documents are visible.
- Keep photos or digital copies at home for quick reference.
- Use a secure home storage like a locked drawer or safe for original documents.
Speak with a friendly agent and get your quote in minutes!
Frequently Asked Questions: Stolen registration and insurance card
What should I do first if my registration and insurance card are stolen?
Report the theft to your local police department immediately. The official police report is crucial when requesting replacements and preventing fraud.
Will I still be legally allowed to drive without my registration or insurance card temporarily?
You generally must have valid registration and proof of insurance when driving. After filing reports, carry digital copies or temporary documents until replacements arrive — and check your state’s laws for compliance.
How do I replace a stolen vehicle registration?
Contact your state DMV, provide necessary identification and police report details and follow their replacement procedure. Fees and steps vary by state.
Does my insurance rate go up if my card is stolen?
A stolen insurance card alone typically doesn’t raise your premiums, but any fraudulent activity or misuse could impact your policy. Always report the theft quickly to your insurer.
Should I monitor my credit after registration theft?
Yes — stolen registration includes personal information that could be used in identity theft. Monitoring can help you catch unusual account activity early.
Still have a question? Ask our experts
Get advice from an experienced insurance professional. Our experts will help you navigate your insurance questions with clarity and confidence.
Browse all FAQs
